Ha’aretz: Hamas’s strategy worked
Published by Hossam el-Hamalawy November 28th, 2006 in PalestineFrom Ha’aretz…
The Cease-Fire / A tunnel at the end of the light
By Ze’ev Schiff
Hamas’s strategy worked. In return for symbolic concessions to Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas - and due mostly to its employment of force against Israel and the Israel Defense Forces’ failure to put an end to the launching of Qassam rockets - Hamas is reaping a major achievement. And anyone who is wondering whether the cease-fire will enable Hamas to become stronger should remember that following the group’s electoral victory, Israel decided that it would not allow Hamas to consolidate its power unless it met a number of conditions. These conditions have not been met.
The positive aspect of the cease-fire, for both sides, is the fact that Abbas, who seeks to resume diplomatic negotiations, succeeded in arranging it. However, Abbas is also trying to remove the economic boycott of the Gaza Strip and gain international recognition for a Palestinian government in which Hamas will be a leading partner. This can be viewed as a victory for Abbas, but it is clearly also a victory for Hamas.
Hamas’s concessions will be symbolic: replacing the prime minister, and appointing a foreign minister affiliated with the organization, but who has a moderate worldview. Hamas showed no flexibility over the conditions presented to it by the international community (recognizing Israel, relinquishing violence and accepting previous Israeli-Palestinian agreements). Abbas will conduct the negotiations with Israel, and Hamas will run the PA. Its control will be looser, assuming that it gives up control of the Interior Ministry and the security services. Nonetheless, if various countries now rush to recognize Hamas, its victory will be complete - and Israel’s failure will be great.
What is particularly worrying is that Hamas succeeded in securing calm in order to better entrench itself. This success was achieved through violence that Israel did not ma nage to prevent - the abduction of Corporal Gilad Shalit and the intensification of Qassam rocket attacks against Sderot. Israel did not stop the rocket launches, and the public pressure on Ehud Olmert’s government grew.
Calm is good for both sides, Israelis and Palestinians, but it reduces the pressure on Hamas, which was in a difficult situation, at a critical juncture. The fact that Khaled Meshal, who heads Hamas’s political bureau, agreed to the deal, and that Tehran and Damascus have been silent about it, suggests that they view it as a Hamas success.
Abbas appreciates the dangers, and has brought forces into northern Gaza to prevent the launching of rockets. The sporadic rocket fire that still continues is being carried out by small Palestinian factions with rockets that they received in the past from Hamas weapons manufactories and the Fatah-linked Al-Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigades. If Abbas manages to end the rocket attacks, this will be an achievement for him. A more difficult task is putting an end to the arms smuggling across the Gaza-Egypt border, and that depends on Egypt. But on this issue, Hamas can also be calm: It has amassed sufficient quantities of weapons and ammunition that it can allow itself a break from the smuggling.
Search
3arabawy on Twitter
صمين لليوم الثامن على التوالي،وذلك غدا الاثنين الساعة ١٢ ظهرا بمركز 16 hrs ago
-
- Lenin’s Tomb
- Sursock
- Shemali
- Through the Scary Door
- The Partisan
- If there’s hope…
- Dissenting Historian
- RedBedHead
- Diskussionsforum Internationaler Sozialismus
- John Molyneux
- Revolutionary Socialist Watchdog
- مشاهد
- The Bureau of Counterpropaganda
- Internasjonal Sosialisme
- The Opposite of Apathy
- Cliffism
- Al-Negm Al-Ahmar (The Red Star)
- أبوح
- Histomat: Adventures in Historical Materialism
- طلاب مقاومة
- Start the Riots
- الطلاب الاشتراكيون
- The 19th Brumaire
- Eyes on the War
- مقاومة
- على اسم مصر
- Le poireau ROUGE pour RESISTER à SARKOZY
- John Mullen à Agen
- Breaking Free
- PolEconAnalysis
- Chez Le Piment Rouge
- L’internationaliste
- مدونة خالد الصاوي
- Left Turn
- General, Your Tank is a Powerful Vehicle
- ROOIERAVOTR
- Jelle’s Weblog
- Punainen kampanjablogi
- Anticapitaliste
- Editions Marque Page
- All Together
- En Lucha
- International Socialists (Kurdistan)
- International Socialism Journal
- ISO Zimbabwe
- Revolutas
- Socialist Worker
- Suara Sosialisme Malaysia
- Socialist Workers Party
- The International Socialists (Canada)
- أرشيف ليون تروتسكي
- التجمع اليساري من أجل التغيير - لبنان
- اشتراكيـون
- Left Punch
- No Ordinary Sun
- Blogging for the hell of it
- Farfahine: Socialist from Lebanon
- 3arabawy TV
- Complex System of Pipes
- Throw Away Your Telescreen!
- SO-CY(A)CLIST
- Pompey Resistance
- Red Eagles النسور الحمراء
- Bookmarks
- What everyone should know about repression
- Lenin: Building the Party
- The Sharp Side
- Reds
- Tony Cliff Internet Archive
- Why do we need a revolutionary party?
- الإضراب الجماهيري
- أرشيف ليون تروتسكي
- Blogging for the Revolution
- Con la Conferencia del Cairo
- John Reed Library
- The Good Soldier Švejk
- Left Now!
- Solomon's Mindfield
- Paul Foot's Internet Archive
- Marxism and Religion
- النقابات العمالية المصرية: رؤية ثورية
- كلمة أبرك من عشرة
- عتبة واحد
- حنين لبكرة
Lenosphere
Related Entries
- Israeli fascist calls for “surgical removal” of Arabs inside Green Line
- US pressing Israel to bolster pro-Abbas forces in Gaza أمريكا تطلب من الصهاينة مساعدة قوات أبو مازن
- Report: U.S. military plans Iraq fallback strategy
- US Senate to debate Iraq withdrawal
- Israeli govt official meets with jailed resistance members over swap
When Haaretz writers say that Hamas is winning, it usually means they’re against what’s happening… and probably exagerating.